Menu
Current Presenter
On Air Now
Logo

Driver who killed York boyfriend in crash while filming him has jail term increased

A driver who killed her boyfriend in a crash while filming him hanging out of the car window has had her jail term increased by a year and a half at the Court of Appeal.

Mia Howarth, 21, was driving while on her phone filming Alfie Lovett, 17, who was sitting on the frame of the open window, the court heard.

She was jailed for three years but the Attorney General said the term was “unduly lenient” and referred the case to the Court of Appeal, where judges increased it to four and a half-years on Friday.

Howarth, 18 at the time, was driving a Peugeot 107 on on Brimham Rocks Road, a rural, single carriage road, with three 17-year-old male passengers listening to “thumping music” on September 12, 2023.

She lost control of the vehicle while driving at 35mph and filming Mr Lovett on Snapchat, and veered into a grass verge, colliding with a dry-stone wall.

Mr Lovett was caught between the wall and the vehicle and died at the scene, despite passers-by attempting CPR, the court was told.

Brimham Rocks Road, near Brimham Rocks. Photograph © Google Street View

Howarth admitted causing death by dangerous driving at York Crown Court in March.

The Attorney General said the original sentence failed to adequately punish Howarth or act as a deterrent to further crime.

Lord Justice Popplewell, sitting with Mr Justice Linden and Mrs Justice Hill, said the sentencing judge was wrong to reduce the sentence because of poor conditions in UK prisons, and had reduced the sentence too much to reflect Howarth’s age.

The judge said: “We agree the judge fell into error in the way he applied a reduction for youth.”

He said there was also limited mitigation in the delay in charging Howarth.

York Crown Court. Photograph: YorkMix

During the hearing, Kelly Brocklehurst, representing the Attorney General, said: “We acknowledge there was a significant amount of mitigation but ultimately it was a sentence that had to punish the offender and deter further acts.”

Glenn Parsons, representing Howarth, said the case was a “profound tragedy” and Howarth’s grief was “overwhelming”.

He said she was “embedded” in the Lovett family and was a good influence on Alfie, who had become a father 12 weeks before his death.

He said the delay in charging Howarth was unacceptable as she had admitted killing Mr Lovett at the roadside.

She also told police she had told the boys they must wear seatbelts and it would be “her fault” if they took them off, the court heard.

The teenagers were on the way to Brinham Rocks, the National Trust site near Harrogate.

Howarth appeared in court via video link from HMP Low Newton near Durham and sobbed during the hearing.

‘Missed every day’

Alfie’s family paid tribute to him after the tragedy.

They said: “Alfie was a unique personality who loved to make people laugh and lived for adrenaline fuelled adventures.

“He lived his life fearlessly and marched to the beat of his own drum without caring about what anyone thought of him.

“Alfie had his own world view that very few understood. He was only 17 but has made a huge mark in his short time and anyone who’s ever met him is not likely to ever forget him!

“Alfie was a fiercely loyal friend, a protective big brother to his two younger sisters and brother and loving father to his infant son.

“Taken from us far too soon with so much more to give, he’ll be very missed every day.”

 
Driver who killed York boyfriend in crash while filming him has jail term increased | YorkMix | YorkMix