Menu
Current Presenter
On Air Now
Logo

Restaurant of the Week: The Oddd Fellows Arms

Restaurant of the Week: The Oddd Fellows Arms

There’s something rather special about a village pub that feels like it belongs to everyone, and that’s exactly what you’ll find at The Oddd Fellows Arms, which has officially reopened its doors under new family ownership.

After being closed since before Christmas 2025, owners Marta and Nik, alongside their one-year-old daughter Athena, are delighted to be welcoming the local community and visitors back through the doors and beginning an exciting new chapter for this much loved village pub.

With years of hospitality experience behind them, the family are passionate about creating a genuine community pub, somewhere you can pop in for a pint, enjoy a family meal, catch the latest sporting action or simply stop for a chat and a warm Yorkshire welcome.

And we recently popped along to experience one of their afternoon teas… and what a treat it was!

The afternoon tea was absolutely stunning, beautifully presented and with plenty to enjoy. Alongside a generous selection of sandwiches, there were both sweet and savoury scones, as well as a gorgeous selection of Polish cakes and indulgent desserts. Everything was beautifully put together, with the whole experience feeling just a little bit luxurious.

Even the tea itself arrived in a stunning teapot, adding those lovely little touches that make an afternoon tea feel like an occasion rather than simply a bite to eat.

But, as anyone who knows us will appreciate, it wasn’t just the food that made our visit memorable!

The hosts took on the quiz... and it was an absolute hoot!

With Nik and Marta’s extended family joining in alongside staff and local regulars, there was a wonderfully relaxed, community atmosphere. In fact, one local realised mid-quiz that they had forgotten to pay and promptly popped back in to declare it!

They were, of course, forgiven... and stepped in to help with the quiz!

Take a listen to the quiz-night antics on the link blow!

And if you’re a fan of a good quiz, there’s even more reason to visit. Quiz Night has now been introduced every Monday at 7.30pm, so gather your team, brush up on those general knowledge skills and get involved.

Food-wise, The Oddd Fellows Arms keeps things just as inviting, serving fresh, homemade food, traditional pub favourites, modern classics and daily specials. There’s something for everyone, whether you’re after a hearty meal, a light bite or simply fancy settling in for an afternoon or evening.

The bar is well stocked too, including the pub’s very own Oddd Fellows Lager, brewed especially for the pub, alongside a welcome ale from local favourites Jolly Sailor Brewery.

The pub’s homemade pies are already starting to make a name for themselves, and it’s easy to see why. Proper, comforting pub food with generous fillings and plenty of flavour, they’re exactly the sort of dish you want to see on a village pub menu. We also couldn’t resist the steak and peppercorn sauce, which was absolutely lovely — rich, creamy and full of flavour, with the perfect peppery kick. 

It’s early days for this exciting new chapter, but The Oddd Fellows Arms already feels like a place where locals can come together, visitors can feel at home and everyone can enjoy good food, good company and a little Yorkshire hospitality.

Whether you’re heading in for afternoon tea with friends, settling down for a homemade meal, joining the Monday night quiz, watching the sport or simply popping in for a drink and a chat, The Oddd Fellows Arms is well worth a visit.

A warm welcome, plenty of character, great food and a family determined to bring their village pub back to life iw what you will fine, good luck to them all. 

Visit: The Oddd Fellows Arms High Street Carlton, near Selby DN14 9LY

Listen Again To This Show